I spent much of the week considering revisions to my books and to the film script. Finn lent me a book on structuring a story intended for a screen play. It is called SAVE THE CAT! (the last book on screen writing you will ever need) It is by Blake Snyder. If you have ever suspected that there is a formula for writing a popular movie then this is the book to send you on your way.
Mr. Snyder is very specific on how to organize a film script and he is supremely self confident that he has cracked the code. I find the book to be one of the most interesting and most distressing books I have ever read on the subject. Interesting because it makes so much sense and once I got past my prejudice against these type of books I found it very helpful. I have gone by the maxim in writing that “Nothing Hard is Ever Easy” for most of my life. But here I am thinking, that if I saw storytelling in Mr. Snyder’s way I might find starting a novel easer and less of a crap shoot.. When I looked carefully at his advice I began to see that it does clarify some of the most difficult challenges a person has in creating a story, without compromising the substance.
The first thing I discovered is you have to have a succinct answer for “What is it?” Can you say what your story is in a way that makes it attractive. Does it “bloom with possibility in your mind’. This is not just for pitching the book for a buyer but, as a creator, it helps you find firm footing right from the beginning. He calls these sentences “Loglines” I don’t really know why but let me try and show you.
A whaling captain goes to sea and loses his leg to a white whale and becomes obsessed with going out on another voyage to seek his revenge on the whale…. Moby Dick
An old man in Cuba goes out to catch fish and hooks on to a huge one that eventually kills him. The Old Man And The Sea
An African American girl has been raped by her father and she begins writing letters to God to cope with her suffering. She eventually learns to form bonds with other women who have suffered under opression and she becomes stronger. The Color Purple.
See what I mean? Frustrating. These read like old TV Guide descriptions. We see instantly that these stories are much more than their loglines. There is no depth, no magic in these loglines, no themes, no poetry is mentioned. It’s as if you are meant to squeeze the soul out of your story before you even start.
All three of the books mentioned above have been made into films. And I have to say that all of them suffered in the translation into film. But that is understandable for the experience of reading a book has to be different than watching a two hour film.
But I still want to say that though Mr. Snyder explains in detail how to structure every film into fifteen “beats” that must hit precisely on their page marks, I still ask myself how to make the magic that we love in films: the gesture that silently tells the story of the conflict, or just the right line of dialogue which reveals a character’s deepest feelings without having to troop out to center stage and explain it to us. Here is where again we have to cut him some slack. Making magic is hard…. and it’s true that nothing hard is ever easy.
But when thinking about making stories, particularly when trying to tell a rich and emotionally resonant story, a lot of what he says, in fact, turns out to be true. Take for instance his advice to understand your hero/heroine. The heroine has a desire and that desire has to be primal. That’s what is at stake in a story. If all she wants is five dollars back you are going to have a hard time getting your audience deeply involved with her struggle. Captain Ahab’s desire is primal. Celie’s desire to heal herself is a deep primal urge. The Old Man’s urge to hold on to his fish even when it is being eaten by sharks is, yes, deeper than just an easy wish to have something. The primal desire often defines a life.
I knew a man who was a serial killer. He was in jail. His psychiatrist said that he killed his victims not out of some primal rage but “out of a simple whim, like how you might eat another doughnut even though you are watching your weight.” This could make a good story simply because the primal urge is highlighted by its absence. He might make a good character but not a hero because we don’t really care what happenss to him and, according to Mr. Snyder, every story must have a hero/heroine that we care about, and the hero must be dealing with a primal (or life defining) urge.
He tears down the movie, Miss Congeniality, which apparently was very successful. (Again, box office receipts are the “coin of the realm” for Mr. Snyder, which can be bothersome for the pretentious English Majors… like myself.) But he seems spot on for how the writer sticks to the formula. There are three acts and each act has five “Beats” - that is things that must happen by this point in the story. It goes from “OPENING IMAGE to THE FINAL IMAGE and include.. 11. ALL IS LOST and, 12. THE DARK NIGHT OF THE SOUL. at the end of the second act then on to the finale at the end of the third act.
What is irritating is, you might ask, “Does it have to be that way?” Mr. Snyder answers, “Yes… absolutely, these beats have to happen at the exact prescribed moment..” And I suspect he is right if you want to sell a popular movie. But there are all different things to write and different ways to write them. One can write a villanelle by following the strict rules, or one can write in free verse. One can write a swashbuckler or one can write an experimental piece about squashing a bug on the wall. I find this refreshing…that there are so many choices. But also I like that someone like Snyder and his ilk have taken such a deep dive into the popular film story. For like it or not film stories in the current moment shape much of how we think about all the other types of stories.
Oh, and what is this about Save The Cat? Well, he says that in the early part of the first act the hero/heroine must do something that will cause you to root for them. He calls this the Save the Cat moment of the film. The heroine must be likable and sympathetic so that you will care about her journey. She must save a cat, or something plausibly sympathetic, so that when she is meeting her greatest challenge in the “dark night of the soul,” moment towards the end of the second act you will want her to prevail: no Saving the Cat… no dark night of the soul.
Can it really be that simple and prescribed? I hate to say it but I’ve been watching movies and I’ve been trying to identify the beats he describes and I have to say that if he isn’t absolutely right about these fifteen beats and where they land then a lot of other people are getting it wrong in the exact same way he describes.
If you are any type of writer I suggest you take a look at Save The Cat and then think about it while watching a movie. The experience is both disheartening, in the way of learning the tricks in a magic act, and thrilling in the sense of seeing how magic is made.
Here is an old poem I wrote for a friend.